Competency to Make a Will: Testamentary Capacity & Undue Influence
Wills are generally contested either on the grounds that the testator lacked Testamentary Capacity (was incompetent to make a will at the time of signing it) or the testator, because of his/her mental state, was subject to Undue Influence (i.e. if there is evidence of coercion, manipulation, deception, compulsion, intimidation, etc.) or an Undue Influence secondary to a thought disturbance (such as delusions affecting the testator's free will in making decisions).
Isaac Ray (1807-1881), the father of American forensic psychiatry proposed that there was a role for a forensic psychiatrist in a will contest, as the psychiatrist has relevant knowledge to analyze available information in determining competency.
Testamentary Capacity - refers to an individual's capacity to make a will. These evaluations are usually retrospective since the issue is most frequently raised after the testator's death.
Since wills are usually contested after the testators death, forensic evaluations to determine Testamentary Capacity require careful review of medical, psychiatric, nursing home, pharmacy, and other relevant records in an attempt to reconstruct the mental state of the testator at the time of making the will. Friends, family members, acquaintances, and individuals who interacted with the testator around the time of making the will should be interviewed if available.
The reports should reflect the case law or the statutory requirements of a given jurisdiction. In general, the Forensic Psychiatrist performing the evaluation should determine whether or not the testator, at the time of making the will, had a psychiatric disorder, a medical condition, or a cognitive impairment, which could affect the testator's ability to make a will. The evaluator should address the issues of whether or not the testator, at the time of making the will, had the capacity to understand, know, or recognize:
. That a will is being made
. The extent of (testator's) estate or property
. Potential heirs (beneficiaries) of the estate and whether or not psychiatric or medical conditions impaired the testator's ability to recognize or identify close relatives and friends
. The manner in which the will is made and distributes (testator's) property
A testator with addiction to drugs or alcohol, if in a lucid interval, does not generally lack testamentary capacity. However, chronic use of drugs or alcohol may result in medical and psychiatric conditions that can impact a testator's mental state or make him/her susceptible to undue influence.
Undue Influence refers to manipulation, deception, intimidation or coercion, made by designing individuals, resulting in impairment of the ability of the testator to make free choices in distribution of the estate in the will.
In determining if influence was undue, the evaluator should distinguish between encouragements of a relative or a friend for a testator to remember him or her in his will, from deceptive, manipulative and coercive actions.
Undue Influence can result from actions by designing individuals (coercion, manipulation, deception, compulsion, intimidation, etc.) or be secondary to a psychotic process (such as delusions) affecting the testator's free will in making decisions.
A presumption of Undue Influence usually arises when the beneficiary had actively participated in the preparation and execution of the will and had disproportionately benefited from it.
The party making the request should expect the report to address the following areas:
. Source of referral
. List of reference materials and of interviews utilized in the preparation of the report.
. Statement of non-confidentiality.
. Case law or statutory definitions for Testamentary Capacity or Undue Influence in a given jurisdiction
. Background information of the testator (reconstructed from available sources of collateral information)
. Psychiatric history of the testator
. Relevant medical history
. Substance abuse history
. Review of pharmacy records
. Review of collateral information reconstructing the mental state of the testator at the time of signing the will and the time proximate to signing the will. These usually include nursing home records, witness accounts, notes and discharge summaries from recent hospitalizations, legal documents and transcripts, accounts of communications of the testator with others, etc.
. Diagnostic Impression
. Detailed account as to how the given diagnosis was reached
. Correlation of the testator's mental state and behavior with legal definitions for Testamentary Capacity and Undue Influence in a given jurisdiction.
The party making the referral is responsible for the provision of the necessary collateral information for the preparation of the report.
*For forensic psychiatric evaluations referrals only by attorneys, courts, insurance companies and employers. The evaluator retains the right to refuse to become involved in a case for undisclosed reasons. Please do not send any confidential information until professional relationship has been established. This summary merely provides basic framework, and does not intend to cover all the specifics and nuances of the evaluation process and report preparation. I make no claims, promises or guarantees about the completeness or adequacy of the information contained in or linked to this website and its associated sites. Nothing on this site constitutes legal or medical advice. If you require legal advice or service, please contact an attorney.
Pogos H. Voskanian, M.D. specializes in the application of scientific and clinical expertise to legal issues in legal contexts embracing civil, criminal, and correctional matters. He is a Clinical and Forensic Psychiatrist certified by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology, and is Associate Professor of Psychiatry. He has served as an evaluator, consultant or expert witness in over three hundred cases in State and Federal courts.
Copyright Pogos H. Voskanian, M.D.
More information about this article at Pogos H. Voskanian, M.D.
Disclaimer: While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of this publication, it is not intended to provide legal advice as individual situations will differ and should be discussed with an expert and/or lawyer.For specific technical or legal advice on the information provided and related topics, please contact the author.